menu
search
BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht
BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Pauwstraat, Utrecht, Netherlands

 Symposium

7 December 2019

BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht  

Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise

Yasmin Ahmed, Barby Asante, Matthijs de Bruijne, Mitchell Esajas, Triwish Hanoeman, Nicoline van Harskamp, Jeanne van Heeswijk, Maria Hlavajova, Natalia Kulik, Andrea Phillips, Laura Raicovich, Shay Raviv, Jun Saturay, Mustapha Seray Bah, Isshaq Al-Barbary (Campus in Camps)

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

  • Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise, organized in the context of the project Trainings for the Not-Yet, 7 December 2019, BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht, photo: Tom Janssen

See the day schedule below, and the full program here (PDF).

Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise is a one-day public symposium on the civic practice of art institutions, organized by BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht on Saturday 7 December 2019, from 13.00–21.00 hrs. The symposium probes the question of how to institute spaces for art in the face of the pressing urgencies of the present.

Driven by these urgencies—such as environmental violence, persistent racism, systemic inequalities, as well as fascisms and micro-fascisms—the symposium engages with the proposition of the art institution as a microcosm of a world centered on social and ecological justice. In this proposition, the practices of the art institution are the actualization of the collective alternative imaginings of the “not-yet”: of “another world” and “another future.” Key to such an imaginary are the constituencies the institution serves, and the consequent re-compositions of institutional practice not only with regard to what western modernity used to call “audiences,” but across all institutional processes. The symposium discusses challenges related to such a repurposing of the art institution, and considers notions of civic practice, collaborative learning and radical pedagogy, solidarity and mutual care, as well as the fallacy of institutional politico-ideological neutrality.

The notion of “instituting otherwise” has been an adage since the inception of BAK in 2000, which has driven its practice as a basis where art, research, theory, and social action meet in coalition to imagine and actualize alternatives to today’s world. Over the past twenty years, BAK has been developing this notion through various multifaceted programs, research, and publications, as well as in intensive collaborations with its multi-talented, poly-vocal constituencies. “Instituting otherwise” is a method of continuous interrogation of the conditions of the world, with and alongside these constituencies, and a way of confronting the injustices in the world collectively and propositionally. It is at the same time a systematic move away from institutions as they persist—specifically in the west and in ways redolent of the colonial era—as custodians of power engaged in depoliticizing and neutralizing the possibility of art as aesthetico-political experimentation geared toward another future. Instead, this method moves toward a concrete, tactical realization of alternatives to the world we know today.

With contributions by: Yasmin Ahmed (activist, Amsterdam), Isshaq Al-Barbary (artist and researcher, Amsterdam), Barby Asante (artist, curator, and educator, London), Matthijs de Bruijne (artist and union organizer, Amsterdam), Mitchell Esajas (anthropologist, curator, and social entrepreneur, Amsterdam), Jeanne van Heeswijk (artist, Rotterdam), Maria Hlavajova (General and Artistic Director of BAK, basis voor actuele kunst, Utrecht), Triwish Hanoeman (musician and cultural entrepreneur, Utrecht), Nicoline van Harskamp (artist, Amsterdam), Natalia Kulik (public speaker, moderator and project coordinator, Utrecht), Andrea Phillips (theorist and writer, London), Laura Raicovich (curator and writer, New York), Shay Raviv (social designer and researcher, Utrecht), Jun Saturay (artist, Utrecht), Mustapha Seray Bah (trainer, organizer, discussion leader, Utrecht), and others.

Propositions #10: Instituting Otherwise is a temporary spin-off from Trainings for the Not-Yet (14 September 2019–12 January 2020) currently taking place at BAK, and is the tenth iteration of BAK’s long-term research series Propositions for Non-Fascist Living (2017–ongoing), which seeks to collectively think and act out ways of being together otherwise. The symposium is preceded by a series of workshops for fellow art institutions, funds, and policy makers in the Netherlands, held at BAK on 6 December 2019. Both these events are part of BAK’s commitment to public practice and aim to share preliminary learnings from Trainings for the Not-Yet, specifically at the point where many art institutions in the Netherlands are finalizing their policies for the forthcoming four-year funding period.

When:
Saturday 7 December, 13–21 hrs, including dinner from 17.45–19 hrs in the Basic Activist Kitchen
Language: English

Tickets (via Eventbrite): 
Regular tickets: €20 incl. dinner / €10 excl. dinner
Student tickets: €17.50 incl. dinner / €7.50 excl. dinner

Solidarity tickets: BAK provides solidarity tickets for those who would otherwise not be able to attend. These tickets provide free entry. If this applies to you, please choose the option Solidarity Ticket in Eventbrite (please note: for dinner there is a fixed prize of €10; there are Solidarity Tickets available with or without dinner option).

Program: 
12.00–13.00 hrs
DOORS OPEN
A possibility to visit Trainings for the Not-Yet, an exhibition as a series of trainings for a future of being together otherwise, convened with a multitude of collaborators by artist Jeanne van Heeswijk

13.00–13.45 hrs
LECTURE
Instituting Otherwise: An Introduction
Maria Hlavajova

13.45–14.30 hrs
CONVERSATION
Trainings for the Not-Yet
Maria Hlavajova and Jeanne van Heeswijk

14.30–15.00 hrs
BREAK

15.00–16.00 hrs
CONVERSATION RELAY
Rethinking Relationships: The Future (Art) Institution (I)
Mitchell Esajas, Triwish Hanoeman, Nicoline van Harskamp, and Shay Raviv, moderated by Mustapha Seray Bah

16.00–16.45 hrs
LECTURE
Manifestations of Neutrality
Laura Raicovich

16.45–17.45 hrs
CONVERSATION RELAY
Rethinking Relationships: The Future (Art) Institution (II)
Yasmin Ahmed, Isshaq Al-Barbary, Matthijs de Bruijne, and Jun Saturay, moderated by Natalia Kulik

17.45–19.00 hrs
DINNER

19.00–19.45 hrs
LECTURE-PERFORMANCE
The Declaration of Independence
Barby Asante

19.45–20.30 hrs
LECTURE
How to Organize Otherwise?
A Case Study from the North East of England
Andrea Phillips

20.30–21.00 hrs
CLOSING CONVERSATION

For the full program with information about all the program items (subject to changes) click here: Program Propositions #10 Instituting Otherwise

BAK’s activities are made possible through financial contributions by the Dutch Ministry of Education, Culture and Science and the City Council, Utrecht.

BAK’s main partner in the field of education and research is HKU University of the Arts Utrecht.

Made possible by

Suggestions from the archive

Learning

10 May, 12.00–12 May, 18.00 2023

Complaint Making: Setting Up Conflict-Positive Spaces for Community Building Praxis

Vishnu would like to share feminist governance tools (FGT) focused on three of many tiers in community building praxis. FGT is based on the values of equity with an emphasis on creating psychologically safe environments, drawing on the use of consent. Decision-making processes, setting up conflict-positive spaces, and complaint-making as diversity work will form the body of this three-day training. Rooted in Vishnu’s autho-ethnographic practice, this work will explore the power dynamics that impact decision-making processes.

Performative

10 May, 12.00–12 May, 18.00 2023

The Diamond Mind II

In this dance training, the people will use a one-minute film of their own movement as material for a booklet—a sixteen page signature—that distributes their presence, their gesture, as an act of EQ. 

Learning

3 May, 12.00–4 May, 18.00 2023

Too Late To Say Sorry? 

A bad apology can ruin a friendship, destroy a community, or end a career. In this workshop, we will investigate the impact of apologies on our relationships and our worlds. Why and how do we make apologies? What can giving and receiving apologies teach us about values and integrity? Should you apologize for something you don’t really feel sorry for? We will explore conflict and how we like to be in conflict with others. We will dive into our own boundaries. We will seek to understand how honoring limits becomes an act of building (or freeing) better worlds capable of holding so many, many more of us.

Learning

28 April, 12.00–29 April, 18.00 2023

Huisje, Boompje, Beestje (D.A.F.O.N.T.)

In this rare masterclass, retired teacher and artist Glenda Martinus teaches participants a thing or two about painting with Microsoft Word. Martinus shares tips, tricks, and secrets on how to use this software to its unexpected potential as a drawing tool. Participants learn how to draw three basic objects—a house, a tree, and an animal—in a seemingly innocent exercise that perhaps contains more layered social commentary. Drawing the worlds we desire does not require expensive tools or education, simply a curiosity to understand how the monster’s tools can topple the house of the master.